Escape artist Matt Johnson brought genuine danger to the Penn & Teller: Fool Us stage with a suspenseful underwater challenge inspired by Harry Houdini’s legendary Water Torture Cell.
Johnson’s performance originally appeared during Season 4 of Fool Us and was recently shared again by The CW, giving a new audience the opportunity to experience the nerve-racking escape.
Before entering the tank, Johnson explained that he would attempt to free himself from handcuffs and a lock secured around his neck while holding his breath. However, one final padlock presented an even greater challenge: it could only be opened by a single key hidden among 20 nearly identical keys.
Host Alyson Hannigan helped verify the conditions by testing several keys that did not open the lock. The one working key was then mixed with all the others before the entire collection was placed inside the water tank.
Once Johnson was shackled and the lid was locked, the escape began.
With the audience watching through the transparent tank, Johnson worked underwater to release his restraints before searching through the collection of keys. The longer the escape continued, the more uncomfortable the atmosphere became. Every passing second served as a reminder that, regardless of the method behind the locks, Johnson was genuinely holding his breath.
The performance also carried a deeply personal meaning. Johnson dedicated the escape to his brother, Jonathan, whose medical condition causes seizures and periods when he cannot breathe. Johnson explained that thinking about his brother’s courage gives him the strength to continue when his lungs begin burning and his body is demanding oxygen.
Johnson eventually located the correct key, opened the final lock and climbed safely from the tank as the audience erupted in applause.
Penn Jillette praised both the construction of the performance and the reality behind its danger. He emphasized that Johnson was truly underwater, genuinely holding his breath and working inside a legitimate locked box. Penn also complimented the way Johnson transformed a familiar “one key among many” premise into something far more dramatic by making the stakes his own freedom.
Although Johnson did not fool Penn and Teller, the duo clearly respected the skill, training and nerve required to present such an escape successfully. After Penn asked whether the keys inside the tank could be examined, Johnson jokingly admitted that he would rather they were not—effectively confirming that the legendary team had uncovered the secret.
The performance is an excellent reminder that an appearance on Fool Us is not defined solely by winning the trophy. Johnson created a memorable piece of television by combining magic, escapology, real physical endurance and a powerful personal story.
Sometimes the greatest accomplishment is not fooling Penn and Teller—it is making them, and everyone watching, hold their breath along with you.


